Conservation Policies: Who Responds to Price and Who Responds to Prescription?
Relative to price mechanisms, nonprice water conservation initiatives induce more equitable effects across income classes, while also yielding greater reductions among key “high-use” households.
The efficiency properties of price and nonprice instruments for conservation in environmental policy are well understood. However, there is little evidence comparing the effectiveness of these instruments, especially when considering water resource management. We exploit a rich panel of residential water consumption data to examine heterogeneous responses to both price and nonprice conservation policies during times of drought while controlling for unobservable household characteristics. Our empirical models suggest that among owners of detached, single-family homes in six North Carolina municipalities, relatively low-income households are more sensitive to price and relatively high-consumption households are less sensitive to price. However, prescriptive policies such as restrictions on outdoor water use result in uniform responses across income levels, while simultaneously targeting reductions from households with irrigation systems and historically high consumption.
- Despite a preference for price mechanisms over nonprice policies on economic efficiency grounds, nonprice policies for water conservation display more equitable effects across socioeconomic characteristics.
- Residential water price increases fall more heavily on lower-income households, while failing to reduce consumption among households with more non-essential water use.
- Voluntary and mandatory drought restrictions reduce water consumption from households with in-ground irrigation systems and historically high consumption
Casey J. Wichman
Casey Wichman is a university fellow at RFF. He performs research at the intersection of environmental and public economics, with an emphasis on examining the ways in which individuals make decisions in response to environmental policies.
Roger von Haefen
On the Issues — Aug 25, 2023
On the Issues: Artificial Intelligence, US Treasury Delay, and More
A biweekly newsletter connecting global current events, pressing climate and energy policy news, and economics research from RFF scholars. This week: Artificial intelligence, US Treasury Delay, and more.
Common Resources — Aug 18, 2023
The Future of the Waters of the United States after Sackett v. US Environmental Protection Agency
In the ruling of the recently decided court case Sackett v. US Environmental Protection Agency, the Supreme Court has scaled back water protections under the definition of “Waters of the United States” in the Clean Water Act.
Media Highlight — Jun 17, 2023
Inside Climate News: "As the Colorado River Declines, Water Scarcity and the Hunt for New Sources Drive Up Rates"
RFF University Fellow Casey Wichman is quoted several times in this piece about the rising cost of water in the parched American West.