Public Management of Deregulated Systems: Challenges and Opportunities in the Public Management of Retail Energy Markets
This paper provides public managers with a comprehensive review of the public management challenges and opportunities associated with managing deregulated retail electricity markets.
Abstract
Many critical infrastructure services operate within quasi-regulated (i.e., “deregulated”) markets. Public managers face a unique set of challenges and opportunities in the administration and oversight of these markets. Administrative and regulatory challenges exist because public managers are required to balance an open and competitive marketplace while confronting multiple market failures (e.g., consumer inattention, imperfect competition) alongside organizational, management, and legal and regulatory enforcement challenges. There are real-world consequences of administrative choices on economic (in)efficiency and consumer equity. This paper provides public managers with a comprehensive review of the public management challenges and opportunities associated with managing deregulated retail electricity markets. It then provides a review of empirical research and an empirical example for one category of these challenges—consumer equity. The paper concludes with a multi-disciplinary discussion of the role of public managers in deregulated marketplaces and public policy options to address both equity and efficiency challenges.
Evidence for Practice
- Deregulated electricity markets present public managers with a host of challenges, including multiple market failures (e.g., consumer inattention, imperfect competition), alongside organizational, management, and legal and regulatory enforcement challenges.
- Public managers are entrusted with the responsibility to deliver public value while safeguarding efficiency and equity. This responsibility exists in both regulated and deregulated (restructured) markets.
- Effective public management requires active engagement with the market to steward the public interest. Simply because a market has been established does not mean that the market will operate efficiently or equitably on its own.
- A pragmatic set of guiding principles and a discussion of policy options are provided. These are intended to help support public managers as they pursue transparent, active engagement with deregulated markets.
Authors
Noah Dormady
The Ohio State University
Yiseon Choi
The Ohio State University
Yufan Ji
The Ohio State University
Samantha Fox
Lehigh University
Alberto Lamadrid
Lehigh University
Matthew Hoyt
Exeter Associates