FEMA Public Assistance Grants: Implications of a Disaster Deductible
Can a disaster deductible for FEMA’s public assistance program reduce federal expenditures and incentivize greater investments in risk reduction by states and local governments?
- The number of declarations authorizing Public Assistance (PA) grants to states has been increasing over the last several decades, but annual PA spending has not.
- PA spending after major disaster declarations totaled $82 billion from August 1998 to October 2015. Three events account for over half: Hurricane Katrina (over 25 percent of the total), Hurricane Sandy (18.5 percent), and the 9/11 attacks (9.4 percent).
- Over that period, the average spending on PA per declaration was $87.5 million. Excluding Katrina and Sandy, the average drops to $50 million. The median over the period was just under $9.75 million; it is similar excluding Katrina and Sandy.
- A disaster deductible would reduce PA spending by a small percentage while eliminating a much larger share of declarations. A deductible would thus save on administrative costs, by reudcing the number of declarations.
- At present, there is insufficient information about the deductible to evaluate whether it would incentivize mitigation by state and local governments. The incentive effect of the deductible will depend critically on how it is designed.
Dr. Carolyn Kousky
Dr. Carolyn Kousky is a university fellow at RFF and executive director at the Wharton Risk Management and Decision Processes Center at the University of Pennsylvania. Kousky’s research has examined multiple aspects of disaster insurance markets.
Common Resources — Jun 8, 2022
Now’s the Time: How States Can Take Advantage of High Energy Prices
Prices of coal, oil, and natural gas are spiking. Although high energy costs hurt consumers, the situation offers an opportunity for energy-producing states to invest windfall tax revenues and make communities more economically resilient in the long term.
Media Highlight — May 27, 2022
POLITICO: "How FEMA Helps White and Rich Americans Escape Floods"
Senior Fellow Leonard Shabman shares his two cents with POLITICO and E&E News in an investigative story about systemic inequality in FEMA flood adaptation measures.